- 94.9LEGITIMACY SCORE
- 95.4SAFETY SCORE
- 4+CONTENT RATING
- FreePRICE
Melvor Idle App Complaints & User Negative Comments 2024
Melvor Idle app received 79 complaints, negative comments and reviews by users. Have you ever had a bad experience using Melvor Idle? Can you share your negative thoughts about melvor idle?
Please wait! Melvor Idle Facebook comments loading...
Melvor Idle for Negative User Reviews
✓ Very disappointedI grinder this game for months and had many 99s as well a built up a bank over 1B. I tried to login yesterday evening as I do every day to see that my save had been deleted. All these months of work just to disappear, ridiculous. Do not play this game as you will get your hopes up and waste all your time. Can’t believe the company takes so much money off people but cannot even put 2% of it towards developing a working game. Please refund me for paying for premium also as this is terrible..Version: 1.00
✓ Accessibility needs improving for Voiceover usersWhen I saw the word “accessible” in the blurb I was hoping for a game that I as a Voiceover user could play. It was partially playable but labelling of elements and buttons could be better, and everything was on one screen making it so cluttered I couldn’t easily find things. I was forced to skip the tutorial as it was even more cluttered! Bottom line, if you’re a Voiceover user don’t bother. There are better games that work far more smoothly out there..Version: 3.0.3
✓ Fails to track offline progressI tried this game and opened it up after a few hours and the most recent save or session is always hours or sometimes a complete day behind. Why can’t this game simply track the time/date on my phone and calculate the figures that should be applied. Anyway this game wasted my time..Version: 1.0.9
✓ MAKE PREMIUM FREE AGAINGame was enjoyable more with everything unlocked, i’d rather have ads and premium then no premium and no ads. Deleting.Version: 1.00
✓ Offline?? Possible??Good game, however it would seem this is the kind of platform game for offline gameplay!! Not a perfect 5 until this feature is provided!! I support this app still! (Paid for no ads) I’m lowering the star rating of this game, developer will not listen to their reviews and also the fact that in app purchase was expensive too! 1 star.Version: 3.0.3
✓ Used to be freeLocked behind a payment for most skills now. Have had this since release and was able to access all skills before the update.Version: 1.00
✓ All gone…I was enjoying the game and what it had to offer having played for about a week, i love the leveling system and was getting into the battling section only to logon today to find my game had become corrupt… a prompt came up saying tap to fix which only works for the local save, it did nothing. I can’t even use my cloud save as a backup, it also comes up with the same message, now i feel there is no point even starting again, because of how easy my game went corrupt, i do not recommend….Version: 1.0.9
✓ Typical…Time wasting game, been aware of steam release (stupidly priced) and was wondering what game was like, as the typical money farming gimmick definitely not worth anything..Version: 1.0.9
✓ Fun but too expensiveI’ve played the free version for a while and it’s very clearly a fun game, but it’s frustrating how you either choose between less than half of the game’s total content or paying $10 for a mobile idle game. I understand the devs need some kind of revenue, but please, please consider lowering the price. I guarantee that lots of people like me like the game enough to justify buying it but are scared off by the price tag. If you lower it then more people will buy. Most mobile games are $5 which seems like a very reasonable price to me. The most popular exception is minecraft, but then again there’s so much content in minecraft that the price tag is justified. The game is good, but put simply it isn’t $10 good..Version: 1.01
✓ Fun idle gameIt’s an enjoyable idle game that I’m currently getting very engrossed with. Very much a work in progress, looking forward to the updates and final version. However, like some other people, I keep getting kicked to the loading page which is frustrating..Version: 1.0.4
✓ Looks Can Be DeceivingSeemed like a clean game with lots of numbers to raise and tasks to complete. Right up my alley! What I got instead was a janky user experience and lots of different design decisions from screen to screen adding up to a game that, while admittedly incomplete, feels like it has no idea what it is trying to be. Forgivable, I thought, since it’s in alpha. On second launch I was shown ugly ads at the top and bottom of the page. So much for a clean interface! You want to crowdsource alpha testing AND show ads to your users? Pretty shameful. There are tactful ways to display ads and tactful ways to release a game before completion. The developer of this did neither. The craziest part is that based on the App Store screenshots alone I would have paid for this app. The world needs a clean idle game with lots of levers to pull and buttons to push. Unfortunately, this is not that game..Version: 1.0.4
✓ Crashes So OftenI regret now paying to remove ads. The game was great fun to start with I was happy to pay to remove the ads. However now I’ve played it for longer the game crashes every 1-5 minutes if I am doing any combat. I wish I didn’t waste my money now, and it’s a shame the game has so much potential.Version: 1.0.4
✓ 10$ to play way was originally freeI had started playing Melvor idle when it was pretty early in development and enjoying the RuneScape inspired aspects of the game and how many different things I could level and earn. I had stopped playing for a while but saw that this game was eventually picked up by Jagex. I was honestly pretty happy for the original developer(s). But now that I logged back in hoping to continue a lost and forgotten grind to see that everything I had worked hard for previously is now locked behind a pay wall is B.S. I’m really disappointed with the direction this game took I had never got the chance to play RuneScape as a premium member as a kid so I thought I could see what I missed out on. Guess not. Guess I’ll uninstall and go back to Cookie Clicker or AdVenture Capitalist.Version: 1.01
✓ JustA sample. Of the most boring “game” ever. An rpg that’s only grind and no payoff.Version: 1.01
✓ Look...This is a great game and I love the passion and progress... but... Those pop-ups when you log-in (man, r they annoying). There are alternatives, they are your competition and their goal is to get me engaged quickly. It works and it will harm your product if you dont adapt. Let me just log in and start playing the thing..Version: 1.0.9
✓ The game has potentialLike I said In the title the game has potential it’s good in some places just now but it could be a lot better in other places. One of my biggest problems with this game is the tutorial it teaches you how to make bows and ruins but then once the tutorial is over you can’t even do they things without buying the “full version” for £8.99 at that point you would be better buying a game like this on pc that has 10x more things to do in it. Also why is the max idle time 18 hours if I’m away for 3 days and don’t touch the game for that long I should have 3 days worth of gear. It’s an idle game that’s what your supposed to do go idle for short or long periods. But if these problems are fixed it could be a great game. I just personally can’t justify buying the “full version” for £9 when I could get a better game on PC for the same price..Version: 1.01
✓ Too expensiveWas about to buy this on PC but makes more sense on the phone. Problem is it’s $12 on pc but $14 here... after playing the free version I think I’ll just wait for a sale.. $14 is ridiculously expensive for an idle game. I’d be happy paying $5 considering I have hundreds of hours on RuneScape racked up since I was a kid lol.Version: 1.00
✓ NiceeeeI do really enjoy playing this game, it’s a sick mobile runescape esc in the way you level up. But my only problem is every 5/10 minutes it kicks me out to where I select my character. I’ve done everything but that’s my only issue. Please help me with this.Version: 1.0.4
✓ It’s fun but….I’m really tired of seeing it in the “New Games” tab in the AppStore. This game came out over a year ago but somehow still there. We get it..Version: 1.01
✓ SorryI give 2 stars because the game actually has potential, the quality is pretty good. But to play the most interesting parts you need to pay 13,99$. That is a pretty steep price for an idle mobile game. Most peoples would rather set that much money aside to buy a PC or Console game instead..Version: 1.00
✓ Mastery reset :(Unsure what’s happened, i’ve been playing this game for about a week and i’ve been loving it! i’m a huge fan of runescape and this is a cool fun idle game.. however all my skill mastery’s have been reset back to 1 today but my skill levels are still the same... kind of annoying and half thinking about making a new account again but i don’t want too haha, what’s the go?.Version: 1.0.4
✓ Decent game, but not loading on mobile anymoreBeen playing for a couple months but all of a sudden I get a black screen followed by a loading screen permanently when opening Melvor. I’ve tried hard reseting and uninstalling.Version: 1.01
✓ Too many glitched and most of the game locked behind paywallAfk’d all night to farm and game somehow didn’t register..Version: 1.01
✓ UI is not greatVery confusing to navigate .. I can’t do searching the shop, it keeps auto scrolling back up to incorrect places. Etc.Version: 1.01
✓ Would like to see this happen.If a 3D character model was added with animations showing what your character is wearing and doing such as woodcuting,ect… it would add a nice touch giving the feel of RS while still staying an idle game. Getting that skill cape and being able to wear it, see it on your character, is what really makes a skill cape worth the while. Same applies to whatever equipment you are wearing. A character view screen where you can create, view, and rotate the character to see 360 degrees would in my opinion complete the feel. Also same goes with combat. Showing your character fighting whatever NPC you chose to fight with would be great. I suggest adding a small box in one of the corners of the screen to showcase the live feed of what your character is currently doing and having the option to maximize and minimize that box on the fly. Sound effects along side this with some RS music would be icing on a cake..Version: 2.1
✓ Poor decisionsI’d love to give this a good review but I just can’t, great idea but hasn’t evolved past a text game really. A nice work around to make a “free” game not actually free by adding subscriptions..Version: 2.2
✓ DisappointedThe idea is nice in principle, but the UI is pretty shoddy. I can live with the very homemade look and feel but have had to delete the app as a great deal of my offline progress has failed to be recorded, which is kind of the whole point of an idle game like this..Version: 1.0.4
✓ Extremely confusingThis is an extremely confusing game that could have been incredible. I wanted to love it coming from an osrs player. UI needs massive overhaul.Version: 1.0.4
✓ Fantastic.Great game. Takes the completionist appeal of “one specific game” and turns it into a fun idler. TL;DR I’m loving the game. But the layouts have some hierarchy and consistency issues which make it hard to know what I’m looking at and how to start a skill. Some suggestions: Make “start/stop action” more consistent across every skill. Right now it’s a little scattered on where you actually tap to start a skill. Maybe just a button right on top. The combat screen is a little scattered, and many of the different combat modes just bring you to the same screen, leaving you curious if the button worked or if it’s bugged. I understand why it’s laid out that way, but I would explore different ways of phrasing buttons or menus. Maybe a “combat” button in the menu with a description of “trains STR/DEF/etc” on the page instead of having each separate STR/DEF/etc button bring you to the same general combat screen. Maybe a large “combat” button with a subtitle inside it that lists the various skills. The first idea could be how you tie everything together. General, grouped buttons on the side, with descriptions on the top, and a start/stop button just below the description. I’ll keep this updated as the game goes :).Version: 1.0.4
✓ DisappointedWas super fun and something you would look forward to checking and managing every few hours, recent update has cut off half the content and charging $12 for an idle game.Version: 1.9.1
✓ Fun SometimesThis game in and of itself is pretty fun, and I can see that it has a lot of potential. I love that it has so many skills and that you can make multiple characters. If everything else worked well this game would absolutely have a 5/5. That being said my game crashes about 75% of the time, and it’s really frustrating. I’ll load into one of my two characters, switch to another tab (bank, skill, combat, etc.), and POOF it crashes and sends me to the main screen. The icing on this crap cake is sometimes when it crashes it will take whatever I was working on with it. (RIP 5k lobbies, countless rune essence, and 3k steel bars). As soon as developers can fix this bug, I will genuinely switch my rating to the five stars that this game deserves. Happy playing and good luck!.Version: 1.0.4
✓ Good game stuck behind a paywallIt’s a wonderful game and before the paywall update all skills were accessible and helped with progressing through other skills but now with the paywall some major skills needed to level others are now unavailable without being payed for e.g. you can’t craft armour or new weapons unless you pay for premium making it very difficult to progress through combat skills unless you previously made some decent weapons or armour.Version: 1.9.1
✓ Has potential but…This game was fun for the 20 minutes that I did play it, and I definitely would have played for longer, but all of the enjoyable parts of the game you have to pay for. I can respect “premium versions” and whatnot, but to paywall over HALF OF YOUR GAME is ridiculous; for example, they teach you about swords, magic, and archery in the tutorial, but magic and archery are locked behind the paywall..Version: 1.01
✓ Random crashes in backgroundRandomly crashes in the background, losing hours of progress; unless I check every 3 seconds to make sure it hasn’t crashed..Version: 3.0.3
✓ Game doesn’t even startApp opens into a black screen and nothing happens. Latest iOS.Version: 1.01
✓ $14 are you kiddingThe game should be a free to play with adds here and there. Instead 2/3 of the game is locked behind a $14 premium edition!.Version: 1.01
✓ Paywall skillYeah it’s kinda like RuneScape. You need to pay for members skills again . Cheap Knick off with no graphics to rip you off and steal your money . Cheap tactics from talentless developers. Stay away from devs like this !.Version: 3.0.3
✓ “Full version”I had really loved this game. I had played it before the Jagex Team (who runs RuneScape) bought them out and played it on the off hours when I wasn’t busy and let it build up my skills when I was at work. The game was FANTASIC… it kept my skills and didn’t lock the others… but after I went to bed the other day and reopened it this morning (Juneteenth) and for some reason my account got “locked” behind the “free” version… and honestly, I’m just done. — no point supporting a game that was INTENTIONALLY free and get locked behind something that originally had built up… I get this was based off the “RuneScape” game… but this is just terrible changes from the new developer (jagex) — I’m at the point of deciding to uninstall… I am NOT a fan of these new changes. I really don’t like when game devs do this crap just to gain a quick buck. It was a fun journey Melvor… but this “adventure” ends here..Version: 1.01
✓ Your not RuneScape.I loved this game. Still do. I think it is a very interesting idea and take for an idle/text based RuneScape. It’s obvious inspirations. All good and dandy. But what I mean, 10 dollars for premium? That is straight hog wash. Sincerely a bad move. Introducing an ad free option, sure. But you made a different move. I’ll repeat. You are not RuneScape. You took the inspiration too far. Now copying their member and non member format. Nah. You guys lost me. 10 bucks Is not much. But this game is not worth 10 dollars, at least in the way you are going about it. And sense you know, your road map seems to have been abandoned. ** It is obvious to see now that this was a cash grab from the start. You started slow, built people’s interest and time. Then boom, pay for access to practically the whole game. Let’s hope you don’t make more then a purchase. You sir, are a degenerate scam artist..Version: 2.2
✓ LairFree to download, but have to buy full game? Why don't you show the price on thr Appstore?. Thief.Version: 3.0.2
✓ Looks terrible and is very limitedThe game looks like it was designed 2 decades ago and so much content is locked behind a £9 paywall. Why would I want to pay so much for a game that it doesn’t seem like much care was put into. The controls are really clunky, really should have looked at some good idle games to see how they work..Version: 1.01
✓ Needs IncentiveIt’s a great concept cloned from RuneScape. But RS owes its success to its MMO and Quest elements. It’s highly unlikely any enjoyable questing can be added, given that Melvor is nearly a text-based game. So this game leaves you without incentive to play it aside from seeing the number “99”, and idling dungeons over and over when you don’t actually need to progress any further. I’d suggest that the developer consider leaning on MMO elements. Add player interaction: maybe a grand exchange, clans, and most definitely player versus player. These elements aren’t just fun, but they offer the player a reason to build up the character as opposed to just seeing the number “99”. But these gameplay features aren’t likely to be added according to the roadmap..Version: 1.0.9
✓ Most of game locked behind pay wallThe free version provides access to less than half of the game, and you’re constantly forced to see everything that you’re unable to do. It’s just an idle game, it should be monetized in a way that doesn’t lock over half of the game behind a pay wall..Version: 2.1
✓ Locked ContentI get it’s in a testing phase, you put skills I leveled up in an older version behind a new paywall. Had you added new content and asked me to pay for that, I’d probably have paid to play, but instead, the way you handled it was pretty shady and you’ve lost respect from me..Version: 2.1
✓ Went from $0 to $13Even if you can easily afford to buy this game, don’t. Greedy developers just need to ruin everything. Why release the game for free only to add an insane price (for an idle mobile game) later on once you see people are downloading it. I won’t be giving them anything except this review..Version: 1.00
✓ Hours of effort lost, truely heartbreaking.So have been playing this game for months and months and it told me to update the app before I could open it and now my cloud save is missing and I had hit sooo many level 99s, it’s only letting me download a save that’s still on tutorial island and not my only character. I had been playing this game almost daily for the better part of 4 months and it’s been backed up many many times..Version: 3.0.2
✓ Two ProblemsGreat game for playing idle but with two problems that would make it five stars. 1. Bank space, just double it. It’s such an annoyance and now that I’ve gotten to 84 slots it costs $350M to add 100 more slots. It was better when it was 1-10 slots but now I have to wait a long time to get more slots when 84 just isn’t enough. I’m deleting items to make space only to need them not long after. I can’t purchase skilling gear from township because there is no space. Just double it. 2. The expansion increased the mastery xp pool amount instead of adding additional rewards. Got a couple skills to 99 so I bought the expansion. Now all of the skills that weren’t 99 have a handicap because the mastery pool increased and I lost a lot of my passive bonuses. This was a glaringly bad idea. If they fix these issues holding back gameplay then it’s a 5 star game. The bank space one is just so obvious it’s kind of annoying they have it this way in the first place..Version: 3.0.2
✓ Update breaks appLove the gameplay and content of the new update, but the app freezes constantly now. It will often hang when opening a new file from the cloud and keep you locked at the AFK results screen until you force close. There’s also an extremely frustrating bug where you open the side menu by sliding it out from the left and try to scroll around on it, but instead it keeps scrolling whatever screen is underneath it. This allows you to interact with the screen underneath as well, up to and including unchecking a box that allows you to eat food automatically on your hardcore character… glad I caught that one before your broken game deleted a few months worth of my effort. Great game all around, but the lack of polish on this update really hurts the experience if you play mostly on mobile..Version: 3.0.2
✓ Great game, lots of feedbackI’ve been really enjoying the game, it’s a lot of fun and the idle aspect is nice. However, I do have some things that somewhat spoil the experience and if you fixed these it could be a great game. While fighting the battery on my phone (iPhone 8+ 2 years old) goes down at a rate of 15% per difficult enemy. This is a massive problem as I would like to use my phone as a phone not just a battle simulator for 20 minutes to go from full power to flat. I don’t know what the hell you did to make it do this but it’s just got to stop. As far as I can tell there is no point to wood and campfires, you can make bows out of a couple of wood and then you just burn the rest. There just doesn’t seem to be a skill ark in the same way that fishing does. The only major use for trees is the birds nests which as far as I can tell have about a 1% chance of dropping. Pickpocketing is really grindy. It takes forever to level it up and it also drains the battery. The same goes actually for fighting although I would say it’s not quite as grindy. Still takes forever though Idle doesn’t work for certain things, cooking unless you double click home and swipe up and sometimes my crops just forget that they exist mid way through growing. There are other issues but these are the most pressing ones in my mind..Version: 1.0.4
✓ Why?I have been playing for a long time and put a lot of hours into my character and now half the game is cut off to me unless I pay £9. Sorry I understand that money has to be made but to cut off a lot of the game that I had leveled to 99 behind a pay wall is a bit severe. With great sadness the game has been deleted from my device..Version: 3.0.1
✓ OverpricedBeen playing for around a year, took a break, came back to half the game being now locked behind a 14$ paywall. Sorry but wont be paying that much for what I had for free, no grandfathered price?.Version: 1.00
✓ Good, but not worth the price for full version.So I got this game a while back, loved playing it. Reminded me of RuneScape a lot which I think is the point. Easy to understand and go about it as an idle game. All skills were open and no restrictions. However, when I opened it up today I noticed there is now a pay wall to most of the content. So all the work I put into skills are now blocked, some even maxed out but now unless I pay 10$ I can’t even view it. Of combat skills you can use only 4 of the 8. Attack, Strength, Defense, and Hitpoints. The blocked skills are ranged, magic, prayer, and slayer. These skills provide a lot of flexibility to combat and can make fights easier or more rewarding. Plus slayer unlocked new areas for you to fight in for better loot so it knocks out 14 additional zones you could choose from. For non-combat skills you can only use 6 of the 16: woodcutting,fishing,fire making,cooking, mining,and smithing. Locked skills are :thieving, farming, fletching, crafting, rune crafting, herblore, agility, summoning, astrology, and magic. I’m very frustrated with what was a great concept being turned into a paywall that blocks me from all progress I had made before the paywalls introduction. I’ll give it 2 stars for how I loved it in the past. But steer clear of this app unless you want to chip out 10$ just to play an idle game. Edit: my review isn’t showing up..Version: 1.01
✓ DemoThe game is $20 and you always need to scroll down. I liked the idea of a simple RuneScape but it doesn’t play simple, it has UI issues that need a much bigger screen than your mobile. You’re better off playing RuneScape than forever swiping up to click fonts..Version: 3.0.3
✓ 5* for gameplay but 3* because of shady marketingI’ve been playing Melvor daily for about 2 months now. Originally bought it on my PC through Steam. Then downloaded it on my phone to level skills when I wasn’t on pc. No complaints, very addictive. Then I get on today to train skills I’ve been training for weeks only to be told I’m in the “Demo Mode” and I’m locked out of skills I’ve been training (some of which I have gotten to 99 just on my phone) and I have to pay $10 to unlock them. Yet I already own the game on steam. Not sure how you can let people download for feee with no paywall and not mention anything about it being a demo then locking them out of parts of the game they’ve been playing. Probably won’t be playing much at all now as I don’t play it on pc much since mobile was way more convenient. If I’m going to play on my PC I’m going to be playing the real OSRS. I don’t plan on buying the game a second time.. Pretty lame.Version: 3.0.2
✓ Costs 15$Costs 15$ for premium membership, i already pay 10$ a month for RuneScape membership im not gonna add 15$ on top of that for an idle game.Version: 1.9.1
✓ Update locked old content behind a $14 paywallThe game was phenomenal in the past. They made an update with a premium upgrade that unlocks extra features but they locked some previously accessible features behind that version..Version: 1.01
✓ Amazing game, but...- so something has come to my attention. I played the game continuously for a few months, then took a break for about a month before returning. As I open my game I notice red text and a lock on some tabs. I click on one of the tabs, of which I had spend hours on improving, only to find that I now have to pay to access this section. I understand that you have to make money, and I know beggars can’t be choosers, although could you allow people who have spent their time gaining experience in these sections access to the tabs..Version: 1.9.1
✓ Used to be fantasticI got into Melvore Idle way back around when it was first released. It was rough around the edges, but you could easily see the potential, and I was happy to be a part of its early development. I stopped playing for a while because life happens, but I looked forward to having the time to get back into it some day. Fast forward to today when I reinstalled it to see the progress, and imagine my horror when I saw that around half of the previously-free content was now locked behind a paywall. A huge amount of content is now no longer available unless you spend money—and that’s not even considering the cost of the DLC. I’m not opposed to creators funding their livelihood through premium content, but when you take away the content that you once offered for free, you lose all of my support. I will happily watch ads and purchase new content packs to support developers, but I will never support the removal of basic features for the sake of pushing players to spend..Version: 3.0.3
✓ Full version?You expect me to pay $15 to unlock a full version OF AN IDLE GAME???????? How about catering to the audience and making it a more reasonably affordable price? $15 is absurd.Version: 1.01
✓ It’s good but….It’s good design and cool but 14 dollars for a mobile game? Rather buy stuff id never need for that much, that’s ridiculous when all the game has to show is more options to do stuff with idle games it’s dumb as hell.Version: 1.00
✓ Good potential.I want to give Melvor 5 stars but it has some problems in my opinion. My biggest problem is dungeon chest loot. It can take a while to complete dungeons (seems many mobs have unavoidable attacks) so you are eating food constantly, preventing you from attacking at all. I spent 5 hours doing the spider dungeon, obtained 17 chests. I got ~300 Mithril arrows from them. That’s it. Felt like one huge waste of time. Not really a idle game if I have to spend hours grinding at one dungeon for arrows I could craft in seconds. I don’t want to know how many attempts it’d take to get the amulet of looting. My other problem I’ve mentioned. Mobs seem to have special attacks that always land. Spiders have a 5% chance to hit me, yet every poison attack hits. Mammoths have the same hit chance, but have a unavoidable attack making them impossible to afk. Skilling is about the only idle thing you can do in the game. My final opinion is just download RuneScape. You’ll be spending the same amount of screen time and actually be able to communicate with others and progress just as fast..Version: 1.00
✓ Like it but overpricedI wouldn’t pay 13.99CAD for it. Maybe reduce the the price by half, I’ll consider paying for the full game. 3 star for the stupid price….Version: 1.00
✓ Idle?Triggers a slight piece of nostalgia for people who used to play RS back in the day and perhaps don’t have the time to anymore. The skilling is fine, idle and all. However thieving and combat? No you have to keep the dull app open for it to process for hours... pointless, not an idle. If you want to play, do it on BlueStacks or Browser, not on phone..Version: 1.0.4
✓ AvoidDev sold out to jagex, don’t waste your time, we all know jagex are like.Version: 2.2
✓ 12.99?12.99 to buy the premium? When the game was completely free.. crazy I’m glad I got to max before this insane price increase..Version: 2.2
✓ Good game but…Played this for a couple of weeks then dropped it when they added a “full version”. They suddenly locked me out of a bunch of skills and then put them behind a paywall. Just play Old School RuneScape for a better experience.Version: 1.01
✓ Pay to play $$$This was one of the best idle games ever made. Had everything a RuneScape fan is looking for. The format and functionality of the game was on point, still is honestly. But since the newest update over half of all skills are now locked. You can not truly play this game anymore unless you can afford to pay. They are a “business” after all I suppose but I figured that’s why there were ads in the game and the option to pay to remove them, but ultimately you could still play.. not anymore. You MUST pay to play now :(… just deleting this game now… was fun and I hope the creator makes the money he/she is looking for, just it will not be made from me. Got to make that money with the forced ads and I can not contribute anything more. Sad I wasted so many hours on this game just for this to happen :/….Version: 2.1
✓ They ruined TownshipLast update is trash put township back to what it was. My lv 120 town was set up perfectly and now it's ruined..Version: 3.0.3
✓ What's up with the slow healing?It's not really idle if you have to keep the app running in order to heal is it? So damn slow too. 😮💨.Version: 2.1
✓ Original player now locked behind paywallI don’t log in often and now half of my game is behind $13 worth of paywall?! I’m blown away, because when the developer joined an app development company, he promised this exact thing wouldn’t happen and wasn’t the reason he was excited to be “supported” by them. Really disappointed, and as a long time player, I don’t recommend the game for $13..Version: 3.0.2
✓ Doesn’t do it for me.I’m happy lots of people enjoy this game, and it’s nice that it doesn’t try and make you pay for anything, it seems like an idle game at its purist. And maybe it’s just because it’s in an alpha, but unfortunately I just don’t find it compels me to play it in anyway. This doesn’t mean it’s a bad app at all, but I cannot give it more than a middle of the road rating as it is not a poorly designed app, but fails at its primary goal of getting me to want to play it or even check on it. I do hope this app does well however!.Version: 1.0.9
✓ Good game but UI is just too bigI really enjoy Melvor on the pc but i can’t recommend this for phone. The UI is so big and cant be scaled down, it takes a lot of scrolling on the combat page, and countless other pages and it feels very uncomfortable. I hope one day it will be a feature but for now the game is just horrible to play on mobile..Version: 3.0.2
✓ Good game, expensiveThe game is good for an idle game. Biggest set back is there amount they’re charging for content with the type of game it is. £9 is way too much to pay for the content that is given. I would understand if it was £5 and under..Version: 1.01
✓ Was 5 *The moment you force people to play the game becomes garbage.Version: 1.00
✓ Loved this game beforeWithout paying 14 dollars the once fun game is now practically unplayable.Version: 3.0.2
✓ Too badThis game was great until they are making you pay to play….. sad.Version: 2.1
✓ DisappointedI’ve been playing this game ever since it was first available. Throughout its beta, you had access to everything in the game. I had gotten 99’s in almost everything and put the game down for awhile. Then it released and I decided to check out all the cool new things. It’s awesome I still have my same character, but half the skills are now locked unless you pay for it. All the skills I need to work on are now locked. I was a range pure as well, guess what is also locked, RANGED COMBAT. The character I have spent many many months on is now useless and I can’t proceed to do anything else since what I do have unlocked is already 99. I loved this game but I can’t play it after knowing I either need to start over or pay $10 just to unlock all the stuff I had access to before for a long time..Version: 1.01
✓ Too expensiveSteam price : $11.99 IOS price : $13.99 I wanted to play the game on both platforms but the price discouraged me. In the end I won’t even purchase any version and I’ll move to something else. I recommend NGU idle on PC. Much more things to do and it’s free!!!.Version: 2.2
✓ Great potential, very limitedThis game has the potential to be something huge. I understand that this is inspired by RuneScape, where a ton of skills are behind the paywall. However, I feel like this game is not satisfying enough to play on the free version. The interface can be a bit confusing, I had trouble navigating the drop down menus a few times. Once you get used to it, it makes sense. I dislike the amount of times I tried to do an action but was blocked by the pay wall. Options that require the full version should be blacked/grayed out to signify I can’t do them, so that I don’t waste my time clicking every button. Fishing provides too many different junk items that fill the inventory quickly. I’m not sure how we are expected to manage the inventory when the space is so limited at the start. The inventory is a little tricky to sort and manage too. Being able to select one item at a time is a little frustrating when you are clearing it out. There should be an option to select multiple items to sell..Version: 1.01
🙂 Melvor Idle Positive Reviews
Melvor Idle works most of the time. If it is not working for you, we recommend you excersise some patience and retry later or contact Melvor Idle.
⛔ Melvor Idle Problems
