- 90.3LEGITIMACY SCORE
- 90.8SAFETY SCORE
- 4+CONTENT RATING
- FreePRICE
Idle Baseball Manager Tycoon App Complaints & User Negative Comments 2024
Idle Baseball Manager Tycoon app received 82 complaints, negative comments and reviews by users. Have you ever had a bad experience using Idle Baseball Manager Tycoon? Can you share your negative thoughts about idle baseball manager tycoon?
Please wait! Idle Baseball Manager Tycoon Facebook comments loading...
Idle Baseball Manager Tycoon for Negative User Reviews
✓ Game Review and QuestionsLemme start off by saying I usually don’t write reviews on games. This game is pretty fun. It is nice to have the feeling of building up a new team and leading them to success. My only complaint are that the players are just flat out dumb. Players run the opposite way of the ball on ground balls, players can’t catch, players throw to the wrong teammates, players try to take unnecessary bags when their obviously gonna get thrown out. I wish there was a way we could control base running and pick where to throw. Other than that the game is fun and I will continue playing. Please make the players have a little more common sense though..Version: 1.5.0
✓ TiesSeems that for the last 50 or 60 games that my team as well as my opposition can’t score even a single run, or even get on base. After 50 or 60 ties it is getting frustrating. Was really enjoying the game up to this point..Version: 1.11.0
✓ PointlessTakes too long to upgrade anything. Just constantly lose to try and make you spend money. Once again another ‘tycoon’ game that only cares about making money. Avoid..Version: 2.0.0
✓ Greatest tycoon gameBelow is what I said in the beginning when I first rated this game……… I take all of it back I can’t even get to the local games because I can’t win the stupid tournament I can’t beat a team that has all level 10. When I have to epic and the rest are rare and level 55 or higher are you kidding me? Omg I spent way to much time in this game and will probably uninstall I just play three no hitters in a row and still didn’t win. This game is impossible! This game has an amazing play feature where you can grow your stadium and play the game of baseball. Personally I love this game and play it often I think the fact you can pay to not have to watch ads is amazing. This game is a lot of fun the only thing I have a problem with is when a runner is running to home and my catcher has the ball. If someone is running to second base he will stand on the plate and right before the runner gets there, he will throw the ball to second base rather than get the out at home. Giving the other team the run every time. Outside of that small factor this game is fun and I don’t feel like I’m wasting my time playing it keep up the good work!.Version: 1.8.0
✓ Used to be a great gameThis game used to be fun, you could just let it play in the background or log on after a little bit and make plenty of money to keep upgrading. The baseball has never been great but it’s an idle game so that wasn’t as important to what I was looking for. Since the last update the game has gone to all heck. Everything is capped and you can barely make enough money to do one upgrade. You now have to click to play each game so you cannot just let it play anymore. I emailed the developers and they didn’t even care enough to email back. The way this game is set up now after the update, this game is awful. I was my money back from paying for no ads before it became what it is. Don’t waste your time anymore. AWFUL!!!.Version: 1.4.0
✓ Playing the game takes to longThere should be a skip/2x faster button to speed things up.Version: 1.5.0
✓ Fun game but the AI is painfulDid the creators go out of their way to simulate Down Syndrome in their AI? Like the level of stupid is insane….Version: 1.5.0
✓ Good but needs improvementsIt’s good at the start you can upgrade quickly however I noticed that when off the game I earn the same amount of coins in an hour as I do in 8 hours when I go to sleep so it takes forever to upgrade items this really needs changing so you get x amount an hour with no limit..Version: 1.9.1
✓ Flawed but has potentialAs far as simulation games go, this one is pretty good. I like the look of the game, the music is relaxing and the system for improvement seems to be pretty well balanced. My main issue with this game is the horrendous AI for the games. Watching the simulations for these games have physically hurt my brain. Watching my fastest player hit an easy single only to get tossed out because he decided to go to second is annoying. My outfielders physically can’t throw it to the bases and my basemen just watch as the opponents run around them for easy points. I know the game is meant to be about leveling up and getting better players, but even High School players know better than to do what these AI are doing on a consistent basis..Version: 1.4.0
✓ Super unfair from the get goThis game literally ruined my day playing it. The concept is nice but it’s so unfair in the beginning and where is the tutorial unless you have to pay to win..Version: 2.0.0
✓ Good or Bad??? Questionable ✅I want to like the game. I absolutely like the idea of gameplay. However the problem I have is the same problem that everyone with either good or bad reviews has. The IQ of the players is so terrible that it’s only good to play for a little while. It would actually be really cool if it was designed to be that way until you upgraded the players IQ just like upgraded their other skills and I kept playing hoping for that but ultimately I felt like I was wasting my time on a lost cause. Perhaps someday developers will actually read through the notes and comments that they supposedly take and do something to change it and then without a doubt this game would go from questionable to great!!!.Version: 1.11.0
✓ Not badIt takes forever when the picture hast to go back to a circle then throw in the outfield can’t catch.Version: 1.11.0
✓ UnrealisticWhen I watch the gameplay silly things will happen and then they get out or get safe when that is completely wrong. Pls fix this game!!!.Version: 1.11.0
✓ Kind of fun. Terrible baseball programming.Worst baseball I’ve ever seen. Things that are in need of changing: - outfielders sometimes throw to each other - infielders sometimes throw to the pitcher when a play is still live - runners can still score after a 3rd out is made - there’s no tag outs, everything is a force out - runners sometimes go for another base despite the ball being right by the next base, really stupid since everything is handled like a force out, even when it’s not - home plate strangely doesn’t out a runner when the catcher gets the ball, unless the runner is close to the plate, otherwise the catcher throws the ball away and allows a run. - game does not end when you have the lead. The game is one inning, and the player bats 2nd. When you have the lead the game should end. That’s baseball. It’s a waste of time otherwise. - scoreboard should have the home team on the bottom, since they bat second. Upgrades quickly cost crazy amounts of money, stonewalling progress..Version: 1.4.0
✓ Forgotten aboutAnother great Neon Play game the developers have got bored of. Would have been 5* with any thought this game might be developed further.Version: 1.8.0
✓ Figure baseball out lolIf you are a baseball fan… do not okay this game. The AI during the ‘match’ play is broken and makes no sense (also developers…. there is no such thing as a baseball ‘match’. Baseball game is more correct… do your research lol. Jokes).Version: 1.9.1
✓ Good design (Terrible Gameplay)I have collected every rare and still I can not make it past amateur league. Every time the team in first place decides to score 5 runs on me and I lose in the last game that would promote me. I have won every other game in the league except for the promotion game. It has become extremely frustrating to watch. Also my base runner will get to 2nd base safely, but will decide to run to third base when the shortstop obviously has the ball, then my base runner is thrown out. One more critique is that no “tagging up” feature has been implemented. I would like to see the user be able to control the runners and fielders actions. Such as putting a button on screen with the choice to advance a base runner or stay put/turn back around. And for fielders, being able to click on the base you want to throw to. It would also be nice to have a pitch selector though it would not be any bit necessary to this particular game..Version: 1.5.0
✓ Don’t botherGame is so basic, 100% need to buy in app to even get close to upgrading stuff. Just a pointless game with its sole intention of getting money from in app purchases..Version: 1.9.1
✓ Great potential but very frustratingI like the stadium and team builder aspect of this game however I found it beyond frustrating that your players lack even basic common sense. Players running off base and not going back onto it. Players going for a ball miles away when someone else is 2 foot away. My players also don’t seem to be able to throw for than 5 feet (I mean my catcher can’t even throw to second) and they fail to make the most routine catches and plays that even at the beginning of the game you’d expect the most basic baseball player to make. It could be a great game but it just feels a little basic still. Still spend ages playing it though!.Version: 1.4.0
✓ TerribleEvery other one star review has already spelt out why to avoid this awful game..Version: 1.8.0
✓ I’d rather watch The Truman ShowPrepare yourself for the dumbest baseball game, EVER invented. As an idle tycoon game, it’s not entirely horrible. As a baseball game, ITS SO BAD. You get money by upgrading your stadium. Let it sit for a while and make some money. Or by playing and winning games. The only problem with winning games, is that your players are all borderline 5 year olds. To throw the ball to second the center fielder throws it to the right fielder first. None of your infielders can make the throw to the pitcher and constantly throw to the wrong base. None of your batters can hit the ball out of the infield. Upgrading the players is INCREDIBLY SLOW. These problems mean that you get less money, meaning it takes more time to upgrade the park, meaning that you are wasting your d*** time with this game..Version: 1.11.0
✓ Just okPlayer was really stupid and this scrap the game.Version: 1.5.0
✓ Lost Brain CellsUpgrading the stadium, collection cash from vendors, and selling Merch were fun, but watching the game play out made me want to cry, laugh, and punch a hole in the wall. It makes no sense why a ground ball to second is being picked up by my right fielder. by the time he gets to the ball runner is headed to third and the ball is overthrown!! To top it off runner rounds third and did out thrown by my third baseman but instead of an out my catcher throws to my pitcher?!? It makes no sense.. lost 14-3, dogs hate me because I’m yelling at them over this nonsense, wife left me because I’m focused on leveling up my abilities and not our relationship, and all I have to show for it is a 0-3-2 season. DONT BUY THIS GAME.. It’ll ruin your life.Version: 1.11.0
✓ Terrible GameThis is a terrible game. The game play is horrendous. Outfielders throwing the ball to other outfielders, runners trying to advance when they shouldn’t..Version: 3.0.1
✓ This game makes me MADSo i have been playing this game for over 2 weeks now and i have a lot of problems with it. First of all the game has major gaps in between upgrading your stadium and field. The way you make money is also very slow unless you watch a million ads. Also when you close the game and comeback after awhile it will show you the money you accumulated while you were gone and sometimes it will show you an option to get 3 times as much and sometimes it won’t let you click it. Well, I just got the option to get 3x the amount i made so i watched an entire ad and after the ad they never gave me the 3x and instead was given the amount that i would’ve had without watching the ad. I wish this game was more fun and would make more sense..Version: 1.5.0
✓ Instant crashComes up with the title Neonplay then consistently crashes..Version: 1.9.1
✓ Please ImproveI love this game and it has so much potential. It’s extremely frustrating when the base runners make the poor decision to run to the next base with zero chances of making it without tagged out. Some of the purge adds are insanely expensive and don’t payoff. The more expensive items should give you more money. The training center upgrades are also way too expensive. IT ALSO DOESN’T PAY YOU A BONUS FOR HITS ANC CATCHES LIKE IT SAYS IT WILL— this part is very frustrating. This game could be so good. Update- the game somehow lost my progress. Three weeks worth of money and my 2 best players. I’m starting to hate this game. Do better.Version: 1.11.0
✓ It’s okayIt’s a decent game to play to kill some time but whoever created it clearly doesn’t know how baseball works and the game is essentially rigged against you. You can have batters with stats 3x better than the other teams yet they’ll get a hit into the outfield every swing while your guys hit grounders or strike out, then try to go an extra base for no reason and end up being thrown out. UPDATE Apparently home runs don’t count anymore. My 3rd batter clearly hit one way over the wall, fair ball, and the outfielder proceeds to run through the wall grab the ball and throw it back. Which stopped by guy at 3rd and ended in a tied game. What a joke..Version: 1.7.0
✓ Just not playablePretty fun game, but there are too many issues to continue playing it. Baserunners have no sense, infielders and outfielders can’t throw or catch despite their stats being close to maxed out. Having a pitching stat of 10 or 45 seems to have no difference whatsoever. The amount of money you can make is so minuscule compared to the exorbitant amount they begin to ask for upgrades. Continuing to win your league is good for extra money until you reach the “Major League”. You don’t make any more money per game after that. People have been putting these issues in the reviews for a year now and the developers have no addressed them whatsoever. Big thumbs down for me..Version: 1.9.1
✓ Godawful AIGet ready to gouge your eyes out as you watch your team make 13+ errors in a 1 inning game. The absolutely horrible baserunning, fielding, hitting and pitching make this almost unplayable. You can’t auto play games while away from the app. Best way to make money is open it up, then close it and open it again later. I had high hopes for this game and it was absolute hotdog water. Wish I could have a refund for my time wasted on this free purchase..Version: 1.4.0
✓ Needs ImprovementThe game is fun to play, I really enjoy the idea of it, but there is definitely some room for improvement. This game has some of the worst AI/logic I have ever seen in a baseball game. Some frustrating things I see my players do in every game include: pitcher running back to the mound before throwing the ball to get a runner out, catcher throwing to the pitcher instead of throwing to a base to get a runner out, outfielders throwing to a cut-off man standing a few feet from them instead of throwing to the infield, outfielders standing completely still when a ball is hit near them instead of attempting to catch it, etc. It’s things like this that really keep me from spending more time with the game..Version: 1.5.0
✓ Fun but needs workThe game itself is actually fun but the mechanics definneed work. Absolutely zero baseball iq for every player no matter how good they are.Version: 1.4.0
✓ Dumb playerNice game but you need to fix player brain because they are broken.Version: 2.0.0
✓ Fun game but frustrating AIGame itself is fun. The AI is frustrating though. AI runs to next base when they shouldn’t. AI makes poor choices on which bases to throw the ball to. Players don’t tag up when running bases. Just a few examples. Also, the rules of baseball are not properly followed which is irritating too. For example, runs are counted when a hitter grounds out as long as there’s a player on 3rd base. Overall I still enjoy it but it can be annoying and frustrating at times. It’s as if the developers read a quick one-pager on the rules of baseball without fully understanding them or the strategy behind the game. Happy to be a consultant if needed 😉.Version: 1.7.0
✓ JunkDevelopers definitely never played baseball. You slide into first. The catcher needs to be on the plate and catch it for them to be out because if they just walk and touch base there safe for some reason? Your best players will be struck out by the worst team even tho u upgraded the four of their hitting..Version: 1.2.0
✓ Frustrating as a baseball playerI completely understand this is a mobile game and shouldn’t expect much from coding and AI, but it is unforgivable how bad it is at times. Your players will constantly throw the ball to certain bases or players that makes no sense if you know anything about baseball. Also, you have no control over the players, which is to be expected, but it gets frustrating really fast when your player tries to advance a base while the ball is literally at that exact base and it’s an instant out. All in all, if you know very little about the game of baseball, or just isn’t as competitive as I am, this game is for you. If you are a seasoned baseball player or understand the game, expect to get quite frustrated at times..Version: 1.5.0
✓ AiLove the game, but the ai is stupid that I lost the championship three times, because of the ai intelligence..Version: 1.8.0
✓ Don’t get if you know anything about baseball.This game created its own baseball rules. For example: Pitcher almost always fields a ball in the infield, the shortstop immediately runs to cover second as soon as the ball is hit. The fielders run back to their positions before throwing the ball, even the outfielders so if it’s a ball to the fence it’ll take so much longer to get in than it should. Fielders CONSTANTLY throw the ball around and miss throws and hits directly to them. The pitcher will often act as a cut off in the infield?? So for example a ground ball to third base he will throw it to the pitcher then first base. Now on offense, the runners don’t know when to stop running. It’ll be a solid base hit to an outfielder and on the throw in they’ll attempt to run to second only to be thrown out by 60 feet. Also, every single play is a force out no matter where the runners are. No fielders have to tag the runner even with no one forcing them to the base. Decent idle game but don’t call it baseball because any baseball players going to want to gouge their eyes out watching them play. It’s more like t ball..Version: 1.5.0
✓ Pay to winThe game starts off well but costs of upgrades soon spiral well beyond what you can earn in game with buying extras. No logic to winning the actual games, stats mean nothing and it’s based purely on chance or fixed results prior to the start. Shame had a lot of potential.Version: 1.4.0
✓ It’s kind of funMy biggest complaint is that sometime the game will not save where you are when you stop playing. I’ll play for 20 minutes or so and out the game down. Next time I load it back up it’s like I never played the previous time and all the progress I made is gone. This is especially frustrating when I spend my gems on player upgrades and then when I log in an hour later all that progress is reverted and I’m topped out on training gems so it’s just been wasting time and not earning gems while I was away. I wish the baseball play was a little more realistic. They play the game like t-ballers..Version: 1.10.0
✓ Players and developers and is this a-ballThe players that are on the batting team hit the ball into second base and he doesn’t field the ball and then the runner goes to second base and he is safe so the runner on third will score one point for his team and the runner on second gets a RBI double. Update this game or I will delete it and let us play the game. Make the players better please. Prices of the stuff is way too much money. Last year I was in last place when I was undefeated. Is that so weird? When I tried to get to the local league I was in second place this time. Sometimes it gets to glitched up that I can’t play the game so can you help us. Why does always if they don’t swing it is a ball if they do and they don’t hit the ball it is a strike. I played another year and they were in fourth place that time. One of the times I played the game there was a animal in the field that took up the whole time of the game. Please help us play the game and keep on trying to update the game developers..Version: 2.0.0
✓ Could be betterThis is a great game with a great upgrade system but I wish you could upgrade a players base running skill. In the same game I hit the ball to second base and they were slow to get to the ball so my runner got to first base easily, instead of stopping at first he went to second. At which point the second baseman got me out after I took 3 steps from first. Then a couple batters later when I had a runner on second base I hit a foul ball to 3rd but it didn’t count as foul and the next thing I know, I’m out on a game mechanic technicality. I’ve read a few of the reviews on this game from earlier this year and they all have the same problem I had and nothing has been done about it. Please fix the game before I rage quit and break my phone.Version: 1.11.0
✓ P2W - Pay 2 Win and pointlessThis game has potential but lack so much. It is almost impossible to upgrade your stadium without spending money on the game. Even then it’s continuous spending that is needed. The gameplay is horrible and lacks substance. It really loses its lustre pretty quick..Version: 3.0.1
✓ Don’t earn skill pointsYou don’t earn any skill points unless you pay for them so you just get stuck and can’t make any money.Version: 2.0.0
✓ Misses the markEverything besides the game simulation is pretty good. Watching the simulated game about gave me a hernia. If the developers could fix the simulation I’d probably change my review to 5 stars. Example: the batter hits a ball to the right field wall and is halfway to second by the time the right fielder gets to it. The right fielder picks up the ball, runs 20 feet towards the infield and throws the ball to... the center fielder. Now the runner is on his way to third, so naturally the center fielder throws to ball to... left field???? Seeing this, the runner decides to head home to attempt an inside the park home run. The left fielder eyes him down, ready to throw the ball harder than he ever has before.... to second base 😑 but the stupidity didn’t end there, because he overthrew the second baseman by a mile, and the right fielder had to back him up. So the play that took about a full minute real time ended up with the right fielder holding the ball about 80 feet closer than when he first picked it up. I can understand the AI making some less than intuitive throws or running mistakes, but come on. Hand held games before the iPhone existed had better AI than this.Version: 1.5.0
✓ PoorAfter months of playing loaded app and it had gone back to the start I’ve lost everything? All that time and now I’d have to do it all over again if I want.Version: 1.6.0
✓ TerribleWorst game I have ever played there’s nothing to do and the game barely works when you throw it to home base it doesn’t get the person out.Version: 1.7.0
✓ Good gameIt’s fun but it gets boring.Version: 1.5.0
✓ SucksTakes forever to upgrade your arena, Ai is incredibly retarded, if you want to make money in the game you have to watch 5 ads. Don’t even bother playing this game.Version: 1.7.0
✓ Pretty LackingIt’s crazy that this is the same team that made Golf Club Tycoon because that game is perfect. So much customization in that game, loads of different things to purchase and make money from. Golfers you get to train and sent to events. This baseball game is so barebones is tragic. There’s literally nothing to upgrade but the stadium itself and the upgrades cost a ridiculous amount of money and barely gain you any money. The vendors are a job. Costing Somtimes millions to buy yet only earn hundreds of coins. This game is 100% dependent on you watching a x3 add to gain money from being away from the game. Atleast in Golf Club you actually could be in the game and see yourself warning money. Not to mention the baseball mechanics are god awful. Players never know when to stop running and always get throw out. And in the flip side an opposing player can run freely around the bases a lot of the time because your infielders act like they have no idea how to throw, oh and only certain defenders really ever do anything, a ball can be hit directly at the SS and he’ll just stand there on the bag and the pitcher or 2nd baseman will have to run over and grab the ball while the runner just gets easy bases. This game is absolutely putrid compared to some of the studios other titles..Version: 1.11.0
✓ Pay to play - AVOIDDDDOnly way to make any real advancements is to pay. Damn micro transactions ruining everything these days. AVOIDDD.Version: 1.5.0
✓ Horrible.Teams with batters and pitchers with 0 everything will hit homeruns and strike out my nearly maxed out team. Team players will make stupid judgement calls causing them to inevitably get out (eg. pitcher misses catch and ball rolls away around 2 second distance from pitcher, team player will stay at base until pitcher picks up the ball and then team player will start running) Would be such a good game if there were actual AI functions in the batters. Frustrates me so much when I tie 0-0 or lose 5/0 because my first 2 batters hit to first base ot directly to a catcher, then get my best and third batter struck out by a 0 skill (stat wise) pitcher. Would give 0 stars if possible..Version: 1.3.0
✓ Poorly executedThere’s nothing easy about making NPCs play baseball and make it look normal but it’s mostly just nonsense at this level. What the players do is clearly not designed or integrated well to actually call this anything close to a simulation of a real life sport. The catcher will be holding the ball while an opposing runner is headed towards home to score and the catcher will throw it to 2nd base instead of simply holding the ball and tagging the scoring runner out. Just one example of many in my watching of 2 innings of play. The game is just trying too hard to just do stuff instead of doing sensible stuff. There’s just so little to interact with while you’re watching the horrendous game unfold that either you’re watching an ad or bad baseball. I would choose neither and uninstall this app if I were you. It’s a shame this isn’t done well enough to warrant keeping it as this is a missing piece in the sports app market..Version: 1.4.0
✓ UpdatedWell, it was good but since they have updated it you have to earn more money to upgrade your stands and training facility, something that was 50m coins is now 329m… and the coins you earn when not playing the game I.e driving my car to work is way less… needs reverting back.Version: 1.9.0
✓ Decent gameEverything about this game is really fun, except for the actual part of playing the baseball game. Players will randomly try to run to another base when the person next to them has the ball and then get out. My player will get the ball and be literally standing on the base but the guy is still safe. Or someone will hit the ball and my guy gets it, but instead of just throwing to 1st to get the person out, they throw it to a different guy. It makes it really difficult to move up. You have to go 4-0 or 5-0 to make it the local league..Version: 1.5.0
✓ Players play like they’re drunkThis is like someone watched baseball once and decided to make a game. Players make crazy decisions like trying to stretch infield hits into doubles or trying to steal when they’re right next to an infielder with the ball. You’re just as likely to get the other team out because of their stupid base running. You save for hours to get a rare player and it seems like it’s always a duplicate (or “dublicate,” as they call it). You have no control over the players, you just have to watch them stumbling around, running into outs. You have to finish first in your league to get promoted, and the clinching game is suspiciously hard to win. After winning three out of four games, I’ve restarted over twenty times trying to win the final game and can’t do it. I’m able to win three out of four but then can’t score a single run in 20 attempts? Imagine the odds on that! Be prepared to watch hours of ads if you want to win any games. No idea how this got 4.6 stars. The reviewers are like, “players keep getting thrown out for no reason. Five stars!” On top of all that, the economics don’t make sense. In most games like this, it pays to upgrade your infrastructure. In this game, I buy new stores, upgrade tiers, but it never seems like a good return on investment. I wish I had more hands so I could give this four thumbs down!.Version: 1.5.0
✓ This game is pretty funSo this game is a very good time passer for sure I like watching all the plays and stuff and enjoy it’s only one inning long 2 innings would be fun too although. The pros: good progression, fun stadium building, vendors are cool, fun training camp building, nice stat building. The cons: runners don’t stop running when they should (there should be an option to advance or stop just like there are power ups), wish it was a tiny bit more interactive like a tap to hit dynamic, position players don’t play the ball right they either run the opposite way away from the ball or they try to return to their preset positions to try and throw runners out, sometimes when the third out is recorded a runner will cross the plate after the fact and it will still count as a run.Version: 1.9.1
✓ Kind of bad but I like itIt sucks because the AI are not smart at all + every play is a force play.Version: 1.9.1
✓ TrashThe game starts out fun, you level your guys up and they start to actually get better then you start moving up in rankings, but then your players just start throwing the ball over players heads and they can’t catch a single throw from 5 feet away, even though his stats are maxed out on catching he still can’t catch a ball thrown by his own teammate. Running is just complete trash in this game, your players will run to the next base when the ball is right infront of them then they’ll be out because they don’t know when to stop running. Then if it even gets hit to your pitcher you’re never getting him out because for some stupid reason the pitcher fields the ball then goes back to the rubber then throws the ball. This game is overall poorly made.Version: 1.6.0
✓ Why?I would have given this game a decent review, but considering the mechanics of the game are sooo messed up, this is not worth more than 2 stars. There’s no reason why a ball that’s hit foul, counts as a hit, or why your player hits a ball, is safe at first and decides to randomly start running for second when the ball is directly next to that base. Also, when on defense balls are hit and your players pick the ball up and instead of immediately throwing to the base for an out, they run back to the pitchers mound before throwing it which causes the opponent to be safe when it should have been a sure out. I just don’t understand why this game was designed this way. I had fun playing the first few games, but once I realized the mechanics of the game, I automatically didn’t want to play anymore. Total of 10 minutes and I can’t stand the game any longer..Version: 1.9.1
✓ You’ve ruined the gameYou’ve completely ruined the game with the needless change to the money system whilst keeping the old prices.Version: 1.9.0
✓ Whoever coded this needs to watch baseballBase running is stupid, most of the times the base runners will continue running even if the fielder has the ball which results in an easy out..Version: 1.10.0
✓ Huge Baseball issues but still funThere are huge issues with the mechanics of the simulation. Simple fielding mechanics need to be implemented to fix errors with who actually fields the ball, where it is thrown etc. also base running is a huge problem. The game is a bit addicting at first bc you’re like I can fix it with this or that. But the more you play and watch the simulation the more frustrating it becomes. Idk if this is what they were going for to make you pay to win but it definitely seems a bit preditory. Definitely a quick get you hooked make you pay to get better players and then you loose interest, they made money, and don’t have to improve the game and then on to the next one..Version: 1.6.0
✓ TrashGame is absolutely ridiculous if you’ve ever seen baseball before in your life.Version: 1.4.0
✓ Kinda boringJust not much to do.Version: 1.0
✓ AlrightWould be great if the AI had any common sense at all.Version: 1.7.0
✓ Fun but flawedFirst off the game is really fun and addictive. I like that it’s challenging so I don’t burn through it right away. Sometimes I think the game is rigged🤣 example, my players will have a quick game of catch back and forth while the opponents round the bases. The opponents don’t do that. Also sometimes the ball will be caught on the ground by opponents or a tile away but they get the catch and I’m out, but when I’m in the field my players can have the ball run straight through them without a catch. Other than that I like the multiple upgradable objects and would like to see more expansion on that. Also, the bunter ability says a guaranteed first base.. but I have watched this dude get struck out with the ability active several times. Maybe it’s just too hard..Version: 1.8.0
✓ Ok so where is the tutorial?Am I missing something?.Version: 2.0.0
✓ Prestige?Game is super fun but I feel that it needs some sort of prestige to get things moving. That being said the game is just super boring at times and I feel the only way to progress is to wait till your coins max out and you have to watch an ad to get 3x. I think if a prestige was added or something to make the game go faster and get more money the game would be more enjoyable. I don’t know if the games intention was to be more like clash of clans or similar games where you can’t really do prestige or upgrade but continue on a slow process and seeing little results, but I think for idle games such as this a prestige mode would be a good choice where it gets easier to make money and you can have a little more freedom when playing. It’s just that a lot of currency in this game doesn’t make sense and relate and it feels there is something more players could do to upgrade their stadium and such..Version: 1.11.0
✓ Fun game but need to fix gameplayThe game is fun enough. I even spent the $6.99 to get rid of ads and I think that was worth it. Where this game falls short is the actual play of the teams. Nothing is done remotely correct. For example, the fielder will field a ball hit to SS and they throw it to the pitcher and then the pitcher throws to first? Outfielder needs two cutoffs? For God’s sakes, the base runners run even when they shouldn’t and are automatically called out before even getting to the next base. even the home team on the scoreboard is on top instead of bottom. So like I said, it’s fun enough but if you’ve ever watched or played baseball, you will get frustrated..Version: 1.4.0
✓ HiHi do not pay money on this game as when you purchase it will say payment not processed go to your bank account an you will see they are lying and you’ve lost your money THIEVES 😡.Version: 3.0.0
✓ AiThis game would be a lot better if the A.I wasn’t retarded.Version: 1.7.0
✓ Bad GameThe AI for the players is hot garbage and multiple times the players have just teleported from 2nd base to 3rd base I cannot play this game.Version: 2.0.0
✓ I’ll wait for an updateThe logic is so off. You can’t throw out anyone at first bc for some reason the pitcher has to run back to the mound before throwing to 1st. Players dont stay on base when they need to. You can make a throw to home plate beating the opponent by half the 3rd base line and they still score and there’s no out. Your best batter will barely hit the ball to 2nd base with a flaming bat yet your opponents batter with hitting and power ratings less than 5 will rocket one over your outfielders. You can hold a good team to 0 runs then your first two batters will just randomly and rarely strike out. Poor return on investment for coins you spend. I have to wait for an update or I’m gonna throw my phone. Still a long way to go. Need a control for runners or something. It’s infuriating. It’s obvious by now after months of waiting for an update that there won’t be one so uninstall..Version: 1.11.0
✓ I really wanted to love itI am a huge baseball fan and a big fan of tycoon games…so I though this might be the perfect game. But it falls short on all aspects. The baseball simulation is missing may rules and basics of baseball. The runners will keep on running on occasions and run you out of a game. A ground rule double turns into a regular ball rolling down the street and the fielders will go after it…outside the fence. Just a poor simulation in my opinion. But it was a pretty fun idle game…so all of that didn’t matter. With this last update, the money made while idle was cut to a fraction of the previous version. So now it doesn’t even work as an idle game and forces you to watch the really bad baseball game to make any progress. The leagues idea is great, but the baseball needs to be better or make it a better idle game. But it can’t be bad at both to keep players around. I paid for the ad free version, but now it will be going on the archive. Just a bit disappointed..Version: 1.4.0
✓ Was ok but update ruined itThe game was ok, passed time and was interesting. Since the new update though it has become terrible. First off the daily amount I would get got cut in half, and the prices to improve your stadium stayed the same making it impossible to upgrade. They increased the cost for players so now I basically have to log in three days in a row before I can either upgrade my stadium or attempt to get another player. If I want to be able to upgrade anything or get players I have to spend money. It use to be watching ads which was slightly annoying but a lot better than spending actual money. Guess it’s time to delete. If you get the game just be prepared to spend money and watch ads, with game play actually not that good..Version: 1.9.1
✓ Needs Better SimulationI saw this game and thought I would be a fiend for it, and quite frankly I am. The only problem I run into is no matter how great my team is, I can not make it out of the first league because of the stupid errors they made. I have 3 epic players, 1 being a pitcher and yet when a ball is hit to the shortstop everyone watches it roll and the other team manages to get a double off of it, yet when my player hits a simple single into center field to the center fielder, he would try to run and make it a double even though that’s not what I want. On top of that, everything is a force out so as soon as my player rounds first he will be out at second. It needs to be improved a lot..Version: 1.5.0
✓ Horribly InaccurateThis is nothing like baseball… my players would miss balls, run to the next base while the pitcher has the ball… I think it was made to be a rage quit game… deleted so fast!.Version: 1.7.0
✓ ChirpsGreat idea of a game but horrible so control players don’t make common sense plays, and can’t control who they throw to, also your supposed to gain skill points when away from game but has since stopped so can’t even upgrade players anymore. Frustrating game..Version: 1.9.1
✓ What a Joke of a gameFirst I have no clue how this game is rated as high as it is. No way it should be more then 2 stars in anyones eyes. The baseball game portion you have no control so the computer makes dumb decisions time and time again. On offense it makes your players run when they clearly should not. It makes even more horrible calls for you when your on offense when your opponent doesn’t score or has one run. It is like watching a tee ball game no matter how much you upgrade your players the computer will always do what it has to do to screw up a key win. What point is upgrading your batting cage and ect when technically it does not help your players..Version: 1.9.1
✓ Developer never played baseball a day in their life…It’s pretty obvious they did absolutely no research on baseball before Creating this app. I understand anyone can watch a game on tv but it’s so much more happening that a casual viewer wouldn’t understand. They bombed they don’t even have the basic rules right. The players don’t have any baseball knowledge. The umpires are blind. Common flaws: - ball hit into outfield, runner makes it to first and tries to advance to second, if ball is thrown to second runner immediately called out BUT he can just turn back and it wouldn’t be an out? - when on defense the other team can steal bases consistently because the infielders and the pitcher play catch (why throw to the pitcher when runners are advancing) then the pitcher tries to throw its way too late and they steal another base. I watched this happen off an infield play and all 4 runners scored - my guy in third base tries to steal home plate while the ball is in the infield (now that’s just stupid) but what’s worse is all the other runners advance to third while my dumb guy tries to steal home and they all try to steal home and they all get out!) triple play on base stealers is unheard of Aight one last flaw and I’ll let you go see for yourself: Last night the opposing team had two guys on third base at the same time smh they both scored on the next play.Version: 1.10.0
✓ Dumb PlayersMy players keep trying to run to 2nd base for no reason as they don’t have time to do so and were safe at 1st base, please fix this..Version: 2.0.0
🙂 Idle Baseball Manager Tycoon Positive Reviews
Idle Baseball Manager Tycoon works most of the time. If it is not working for you, we recommend you excersise some patience and retry later or contact Idle Baseball Manager Tycoon.
⛔ Idle Baseball Manager Tycoon Problems
