Madtale: Idle RPG Negative Reviews

Madtale: Idle RPG App Complaints & User Negative Comments 2024

Madtale: Idle RPG app received 29 complaints, negative comments and reviews by users. Have you ever had a bad experience using Madtale: Idle RPG? Can you share your negative thoughts about madtale: idle rpg?

Madtale: Idle RPG for Negative User Reviews

✓ P2W gameIf you don’t pay, there is almost no way to play this game. You will be beat by players and by NPCs! I like this game at first, then they just invented hundreds ways to ask for money. Unlike other similar P2W game, there not much free resources for normal players to enjoy the game at all!.Josh-AVersion: 1.0.6

✓ Okay this may be just me but…Okay so I was really excited for this game because of the ads and everything that was promised. And I waited like a few weeks for it to come out. So I downloaded this game and while the graphics were cool, the storyline and the game were nothing like expected and were kind of boring. In addition the game is not very compatible with an iPad as it was smaller than my screen size. So I didn’t have a good experience, sorry….Pixelated150Version: 1.0.5

✓ Ne fonctionne pasNe fonctionne pas. Cherche une serveur de mise à jour indéfiniment lorsqu’on lance le jeux..MrPlateauMtlVersion: 1.0.5

✓ Very strong start, falling flat to p2wI really enjoyed this game up until the last few weeks. The story was fun, the characters interesting. However, it became increasingly difficult to find people actually PLAYING. As of this week, only three guilds in my server are actually active and half of them haven’t been on in a week. This is likely due to predatory micro transactions and the nerfing of characters. You hit a wall mid late game that frankly, all the free pulls in the world can’t get you past. You have to pay money or you just sit. I’ve finally given up. Between being bombarded by pages and pages of micro transactions and paywalled from certain features, to having absolutely zero people actively playing on my server leaving me feeling like I’m in a ghost town, this game is dead before it even really got on its own two legs..KotngotnVersion: 1.0.9

✓ MehCute story, cute characters, cute art, that’s really all that this game has to offer. The gameplay is just ok. It gets really boring really quick. Resources are also really annoying to grind for, despite being very important, seeing as the game seems to expect you to level up very fast at the very beginning. So, having characters levels locked behind resources you can’t grind for is very annoying. This game is definitely not for everyone. Wouldn’t recommend unless you’re willing to invest money into it..🐸Reahramlove1🦊Version: 1.0.12

✓ Fun but terrible supportThis is a pretty fun AFK Arena clone with excellent artwork, but the customer support is terrible. I was double charged for a purchase, and when I reached out to support, they said they would fix it. This was two weeks ago. So buyer beware, they don’t care about their players..EhEhRon79Version: 1.0.7

✓ Unfair alga rythme & some packs over $100Sure the graphics are breathtaking but they’re about grabbing a LOT of money from you and not giving good quality customer service regarding fixing issues. You’re on 1 server but Guilds are matched haphazardly with other guilds of other servers that can greatly outrank you. They claim “matching is based on the power of your guild” but it isn’t the case… all players were twice the capacity of all of ours in one nightmare match. Instead of correcting the alga rythme they let you rot. Language issues: They might be based in Singapore or somewhere similar (their web pay offers lead there) but the translation SUCKS! Sometimes there are asian characters. The grammar and sense is subpar. Do you want to pay hundreds of dollars? Ok, the game doesn’t have ads… except their own trying to get you to spend. The better quality offers are over $100 CDN… yet don’t give you a huge advantage. E.g., buy a S+ but you get Epic level so to get to max (glitter 5) you need multiple of them so you would need to buy repetitively which would be around a thousand real cash… for just one character. Also, want to advance with your characters? After you bring them to 160 you cannot advance unless you use S and S+ characters. You need identicals to consume to get +, which is 1 out of 2 promotions. Unless you pay a LOT it is very hard to obtain. Many higher players quit at this point. To advance higher characters, they must be linked… but link blocks lvl advancement unless all are certain lvl. E.g. Can’t go above 200 until all linked are 180. More players quit at this point. It’s a manipulative cash grab & low customer service game..NicknameMLVersion: 1.0.8

✓ DisappointingThe game at first is very fun but then it starts getting boring and more and more P2w. There are also mistakes in characters story like grammar errors, repeated words, mistakes, etc. It’s almost impossible to get a character that’s more than epic for free. Thanks for reading. Please don’t reply to this comment..IdkwkkVersion: 1.0.7

✓ Can’t connect to server - UpdateGame booted me last night and I still can’t login today. Update - deleted and reinstalled the game, and was able to login. Unfortunately, I had to go through tutorial again to login to my account. With that being said, this game still crashes multiple times a session. Still seems really unstable..TAG1975Version: 1.0.7

✓ Pay to winI would give the game a 5 star’s rating. When start up the game you get bombarded with ads. You’re doing the same thing over and over again. I have been playing this game for three weeks. it’s getting very repetitive. Suggestion cut the amount of adds back. Then it will become a better game. Plus give the human the ability to control the toons in the fight..DarkdevilrejectVersion: 1.0.7

✓ Slow progression & p2wOnce the honeymoon phase ends which is extremely fast (2-3 days) progression comes to a major halt which is typical of these idle games but this tops the cake for the slowest of them all. The game is also blatantly p2w with dozens of battle passes and a vip system that can only be upgraded with real money that is way to expensive for what it’s worth. Now I wouldn’t have an issue with it if it wasn’t shoved in my face everywhere I click. It’s first event is also awfully p2w which is a major red flag in any mobile game. Honestly just stick with AFK Arena which is a lot more f2p friendly and has a better community that isn’t just Disney adults..SHOOKSNAPEVersion: 1.0.7

✓ Good start but hear me outYou got a good start on this one. Nice art style and simple and effective gameplay, it’s nice. But one problem I found. When in combat, the fighting only takes up half the screen. To me, this is a bad design choice because while watching, it starts to hurt your eyes after not long of watching. Everything else is pretty good, but if you can fix that one issue, that would be great. If you don’t, that’s fine too..YamegaVersion: 1.0.5

✓ DisappointedWhen I started playing it had an option to pick a character of your choosing after a certain number of summons and you would be guaranteed to get that character and that felt like my time was not wasted but now they have changed it to picking one of the factions and the character you get is rng based. No point in spending more time on a game that doesn’t appreciate its players..Horror MuppetVersion: 1.0.10

✓ UnplayableThis game is absolutely merciless about how uncommonly they’ll give you rewards, and about how minuscule they’ll be. It costs 2800 diamonds to summon a 10-pack of characters, and you get 10 diamonds when you level up, just to put it in perspective. You also don’t get any at all when you beat levels, and the new player rewards/ pre-registration rewards provided a collective total of around 500 diamonds. Are you serious? How scummy can you be? This doesn’t even feel like a game, it’s nothing short of a scam.Fjanr cnVersion: 1.0.7

✓ Stingy but worth a tryThe game is overtly pay to play. The rewards are really low so it’s difficult to summon and subsequently build heros. It’s a real shame because the game looks gorgeous and is fun to play. Progression is slow and unrewarded but it’s worth trying to see if it’s your speed..Davo SVersion: 1.0.7

✓ Needs optimisation and QoL FeaturesBehind all the bad optimisation or terrible UI, there’s a fun idle game hidden. This game is in serious need of optimisation. There’s this constant touch lag throughout the game. There’s no reason for this game to run this slow. What made me drop this game is the constant RED DOTS EVERYWHERE!!! There are countless menus and sub menus filled with red dots to collect different resources. It is highly annoying and done on purpose to keep user engagement…..but it has the opposite effect. This game is in serious need of QoL features. Also this is the first game I’ve played with a VIP system that you can only progress with money. I played the game for about 2 months and my VIP level was always at 0. There’re also too many modes for an idle game. At one point my friend list was bugged where I couldn’t collect friend points for about a week, and would disconnect me back to the title screen. When it was fixed, my friend list was blank. There was no in game mail about the issue or any compensation. There’s no in game support for issues, only a quick email pop at the title screen which flashes for 1 second. I liked the different character designs and building team comps, but logging in daily and going through all the red dots to clear and lag is a killer..Danny81zVersion: 1.0.12

✓ Fun, but it will absolutely cost you.I played for a while, spent ~30$. It’s compelling because the character designs are so good. Immediately it becomes pay to play, that’s just how these games work. I had a pretty good team going, attempting higher content, straining a bit. The Cinderella “offer” pops up. She’s clearly a must have character, and I can buy her for only 50$ vs. the other 99$ offers I’d ignored. Deleted the game. If you want to pay and play, it’s nice. I don’t. It’s greedy..AarontwoodsworthVersion: 1.0.7

✓ Baker FreezesI am in the same situation as the person above. I get to the baker and it freezes and can not play anymore. Please fix this..Mantra77Version: 1.0.12

✓ Disappointed but expectedBeen playing nonstop for the last few days. paywall sets in around chapter 12 bc the enemies start to get past level 100 and if you have some s+ characters, you need to roll for them again in order to promote and level them past lvl 100. around chapter 11 is when it’s starting to get hard to grind for memory essence (needed to lvl characters) you get around 6000 essence per level but i currently need around 30-40k to level a 90 level character up. not much else to grind for and i’m disappointed but i did expect it.BlackshadoelemonVersion: 1.0.6

✓ Kind of boringThe art is nice, and the story seems interesting but the dialogue is clunky and very awkward. The bad dialogue could be excused if the fighting was good; but its non-existent. Maybe I just haven't seen the button, but by default you can’t fight battles it is automatically done. No fighting would be interesting if the story wasn't so awkward and poorly written. The way characters speak is extremely artificial and its clear they are only there to explain what’s happening in the current moment. Show don’t tell, basic rule of writing..Anatra LesbicaVersion: 1.0.5

✓ Nothing is done about blatant cheatingYou know what the most ridiculous thing I just saw today? I just saw the 2 strongest players of the whole game nearly double in strength overnight. I know because I’m in the same server as them. These dudes were already around 150m+. It would take a FORTUNE to reach 150m, and at 441m you’d have to be a ceo billionaire. Safe to say, I’m not going keep playing a game that does nothing about cheaters :/ And the voice acting is sub-par at best, with Snow White being the WORST! Like someone scratching a blackboard bad!.Spilled TeaVersion: 1.0.12

✓ Not an idle gameI liked this game at first. The design is unique. But the story is confusing and not well written, the hero skills are completely underwhelming, there are too many things to do daily for too few rewards, and they seem to be lying directly in the game since they say you will get 1024 free summons and you get 90. I wanted an idle game that would take up maybe a half hour a day, not something that has so many daily tasks that it ends up feeling like a job. I’m already have one of those, thanks..ZsenineVersion: 1.0.7

✓ Copy of afk arena and just as greedyThis is just the exact same game as afk arena but reskinned. Overall art and concept isn’t bad. It seems like more work has been done on micro-transitions baiting than anything else, there are so many cash pages where you have to keep going into for things. The rates are so bad for you to get decent units let alone multiple. Save yourself the money before it’s too late..IceydealerVersion: 1.0.6

✓ Wish I could give 5 starsI want to play this game more than I do. Here’s what makes me put down the game, and why I’m going to delete it, in spite of the fact that I like the art and the battles and the collection and the character growth aspect. 1) My phone heats up (iphone 13 mini) 2) It feels a little laggy or unresponsive. Like I have to tap on things sort of deliberately and sometimes it takes a second to respond. 3) Way too confusing on all the in app purchases and different currencies and events. It’s just way too much to sort through and figure out, and doesn’t add to the fun of the game. I know I’m missing out on rewards in part just because it’s so incredibly cluttered and confusing 4) Way too many iaps. Another thing going on with all these iaps is that even though I’d be willing to spend up to $20 I know that it wouldn’t matter. There’s constantly “top up” events and temporary packs and so much stuff that I know I would fall so far behind and eel like I missed out, so I might as well not play at all..Dawna joVersion: 1.0.9

✓ Good potential but…Its a really fun concept & i love the story & character designs, but some parts of the game annoy me. The characters' voices are inconsistant & it really throws me off. Alot of the dialogue is also hard to understand to the point of me getting very confused. The grammar is very off & it would be easier for me to get immersed in the game if it was fixed or proof read at least.Fionna MlpVersion: 1.0.7

✓ Fun for a week only. Pay2win gameThis game is fun for a week only if you’re free to play. Take it as a trial run. You can’t progress without having to “idle” for exp or other stuff you need to level up the characters. I’ve gone as far as I can in story and shadow thing. There’s nowhere else to farm for what I need. BUT they do have one million ways to sell you things for real money. 3 popups when you open the game. All the side panels are “events” aka time limited promotions to make you spend real money. When those are over, new events pop up. 2 stars because I actually enjoyed it while I could..HduosnrcVersion: 1.0.7

✓ Game is incredibly broken.I can’t even ask for customer support cause it won’t let me. My game constantly freezes after visiting my guild. Domination’s deployment replacement is broken. I can’t replace my defense team at all. So it is stuck from two dominations ago. Even if it doesn’t make sense cause my levels don’t even match the units in the defense. Like my strength is almost 900k but it is stuck on 362k in domination. The events are entirely pay to win and not worth playing. Everything about this game is dedicated to pay to win and borderline driving me insane with how much it freezes! Even the update is frozen as I am typing this! Fix your game! They seriously need to fix their bugs before releasing it or game test it!.R.P.A.W.S.T.M.N.Version: 1.0.10

✓ Edit:Misleading Pre-registration bonusI’ve had this game pre-registered since MARCH. I seen the promo saying I would get MIRROR QUEEN and other rewards, so I expected to have just that. However today is GLOBAL LAUNCH DAY, and there were NO PRE-REGISTRATION REWARDS. What the website or promos doesn’t tell you is that there are TWO different ways to sign up. One way will get you all the rewards, and the other way is just a standard sign up. I deleted two other games I was playing to get this game today since I PRE-REGISTERED. I WANT MY REWARDS or I WILL DELETE THIS GAME!!! Edit: Rewards have been sent. Now I’m grinding out the game to see how fun it is..QdamaVersion: 1.0.6

✓ DullSo very dull. Tap a billion times to get to a fight, the fight happens automatically, then tap a billion more times to go to the next one..Anon123321Version: 1.0.6

Madtale: Idle RPG works most of the time. If it is not working for you, we recommend you excersise some patience and retry later or contact Madtale: Idle RPG.